The short answer

Something breaks in the third month. Three things can happen next — repair, replacement, refund — and which one you are owed depends on which of three separate things you are relying on. The page a store shows you first is about a different one.

A return window is the store's own voluntary promise: 14 or 30 days on the returns page, usually expired long before a defect appears. A warranty is a promise about the product's condition over time; in the United States the written version is governed by the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, and the FTC's Businessperson's Guide to Federal Warranty Law is the source for most of what follows. A consumer guarantee is statutory and exists whether or not the store wrote anything; Australia's sits in the Australian Consumer Law, and the ACCC's page on consumer rights and guarantees is the second source here.

They answer the question in a specific order. Under the FTC's five tests for a full warranty, repair comes first and the choice comes after repair has failed: a full warrantor must "provide, at the consumer's choice, either a replacement or a full refund if, after a reasonable number of tries, you are unable to repair the product." Under a limited warranty none of that is required. And postage is not a side issue in that scheme — it is one of the five dividing lines, because a full warrantor must "provide warranty service free of charge," and the FTC's own sample limited warranty is limited precisely because "there are requirements that the customer pay labor and postage charges."

What neither source does is say who pays freight across a border. The FTC page is about who performs and pays for warranty service, not about a parcel going back to China; the ACCC page lists four remedies — repair, replacement, refund and cancel — and does not allocate freight at all. So the honest answer is that the two authorities read for this guide do not say — and our own records barely do either: eight of 91 put a freight term next to a warranty.

What "limited" actually limits

A common misreading is that "limited warranty" means no warranty. The FTC's definition is narrow enough to quote whole:

"Full Warranty" means the coverage meets the federal minimum standards for comprehensive warranties, while "Limited Warranty" means the coverage does not.

That is the whole distinction: a label for a warranty failing at least one of five tests, not a synonym for worthless. The guide warns that "the legal meanings of the words 'full' and 'limited' in written consumer product warranties are far more narrow and specific than they are in ordinary usage."

The tests: "If each of the following five statements is true about your warranty's terms and conditions, it is a 'full' warranty":

  1. "You do not limit the duration of implied warranties."
  2. "You provide warranty service to anyone who owns the product during the warranty period."
  3. "You provide warranty service free of charge."
  4. "You provide, at the consumer's choice, either a replacement or a full refund if, after a reasonable number of tries, you are unable to repair the product."
  5. "You do not require consumers to perform any duty as a precondition for receiving service, except notifying you that service is needed, unless you can demonstrate that the duty is reasonable."

"If any of these statements is not true, then your warranty is 'limited.'"

Four consequences follow. Test 4 is the only place the three remedies are ranked — repair first, "after a reasonable number of tries", then replacement or refund "at the consumer's choice". A store offering repair and nothing else has written a limited warranty, and the limitation is that fourth test. Postage sits inside the definition: test 3 says service free of charge, and the sample warranty is limited because the customer pays labour and postage and returns a registration card. That phrase is the closest either source comes to answering who pays to send the thing back. A registration card cannot be a precondition: "Requiring customers to return a registration card is an unreasonable duty that is not allowed in a full warranty." The label carries obligations: every written warranty on a consumer product costing more than $10 must be titled full or limited, and the title "alerts consumers that the coverage does not meet at least one of the Act's standards"; the disclosure and pre-sale rules bite above $15.

What a limited warranty still leaves you

The implied warranty of merchantability survives the label. The guide calls it "a merchant's basic promise that the goods sold will do what they are supposed to do and that there is nothing significantly wrong with them," and draws the consequence: "In such a case, the law requires you to provide a remedy so that the buyer gets a working oven." It promises a remedy and a working product; it never names repair, replacement or refund.

It also cannot be disclaimed away: "Federal law prohibits you from disclaiming implied warranties on any consumer product if you offer a written warranty for that product." A store publishing a limited warranty has given up the right to sell "as is". What the implied warranty does not do is last: the statutes of limitations are "generally four years from date of purchase" — a window for a claim, not four years of function — and it excludes "problems such as those caused by abuse, misuse, ordinary wear, failure to follow directions, or improper maintenance."

The floor is also lower than buyers assume: "the Act does not require any business to provide a written warranty." A store with no warranty page has broken no federal rule; what you are left with is whatever implied warranty it has not disclaimed — and a written warranty is what would have stopped it disclaiming one. And the written word is all that counts federally: "the Act does not apply to oral warranties. Only written warranties are covered."

The guarantee a sign cannot cancel

Australia starts elsewhere: the rights exist before the store writes anything.

The basic rights covered by consumer guarantees can't be taken away by anything a business says or does.

The page lists what that rules out — "displaying a 'no refunds' sign, or otherwise saying that refunds are not available at all, or not available at all after a certain number of days", or "saying they aren't responsible for problems with a product or service" — and states the consequence: "It is against the law for businesses to mislead consumers about their rights in these ways."

The relation between the two instruments is set out in one paragraph, and it is the cleanest statement of this article's subject:

Consumer guarantees are automatic and can't be taken away. Warranties are extra promises that a business can choose to make on top of the consumer guarantees.

So a warranty is additional to the guarantee, never a substitute: a warranty promising less than the guarantee does not reduce your rights, because the guarantee sits underneath regardless.

The core guarantee is acceptable quality, and it has no fixed clock: "There are no set rules for deciding whether a product is of acceptable quality, or how long a product should last for." The guarantee that speaks most directly to a broken appliance is separate: "When a consumer buys a product, the manufacturer or importer must provide spare parts and repair facilities for a reasonable time after purchase. This applies even if the consumer did not buy the goods directly from the manufacturer or importer." Its exception is a disclosure made at purchase — the guarantee "does not apply if the consumer is told at the time of purchase that repair facilities and spare parts will not be available after a certain time."

On who to chase: "Your first step is to contact the business that sold the product or service to explain the problem. The business can't refuse to help you by telling you to contact the manufacturer." The repairs guarantee is the single exception in the page's text. On the remedy: "Depending on the situation, the remedy may be: repair, replacement, refund, cancel" and "compensation for damages or loss." Note may be: this page lists the remedies and does not rank them, and the linked ACCC guide that would explain the ranking was not read. Unlike the FTC Act, spoken promises are covered — extra promises "must meet these promises. This applies whether the promises are spoken or written."

And then the regulator states the limit

The same page is candid about sellers abroad:

When an overseas business sells products directly to consumers in Australia, the business must follow the Australian Consumer Law, including the consumer guarantees. In practice it can be difficult to get a repair, replacement or refund from an overseas business if there's a problem with the product or service, and the help Australian consumer protection agencies can provide is limited.

Two floors under that: the law does not reach a business that "doesn't officially offer their products and services in Australia", and the ACCC says what it will not do — "We don't provide legal advice about what consumers are entitled to" and "We don't resolve individual disputes about whether the consumer guarantees have been met or the remedy." The guarantee is automatic, cannot be signed away, and by the regulator's own account is hard to enforce against the sellers this site writes about. It tells you what you are owed; it does not make the parcel come back.

Thirteen of 91

Our own records make the same point with a number small enough to check. This site published 91 store records with both status published and review_state approved on 18 November 2026 at 17:48 (UTC+08:00); the thirteen below are the records that matched on that date, re-checked against the current database. Across their summary fields — return policy, shipping time, destinations, payment methods, tagline, self-description — the word warranty appears in thirteen: Anker, COSORI, CYCPLUS, ELEGOO, Kingroon, Linsoul, Nebula, Renpho, Sovol, TerraMaster, TP-Link, VIOFO and Xiaomi. One uses "limited warranty" — COSORI's record reads "defects after that period go to the limited warranty."

The rest is thinner:

  • 1 of 91 mentions repair as an outcome, and 2 mention replacement: ELEGOO in both cases, plus Chicme's "a refund or replacement/exchange within 30 days of delivery".
  • 3 of 91 carry any month or year in figures in the return summary: Kingroon's "a 1-year warranty" in its refund policy, Linsoul's "Warranty runs 1 year, 3 months for cables and adapters", and VIOFO's competing "12-month", "18 months" and "24 after registration".
  • 23 of 91 mention a defect and 23 mention a restocking fee (several only to say none is charged); at least 59 put return freight on the buyer in at least one situation, 34 record the store paying it in at least one situation, and 5 record a label whose cost is taken out of the refund. Counts over one field, mostly about change-of-mind returns, not defects.

A blank is not a denial. These are summary fields, and a warranty usually lives on a separate policy page a returns summary has no reason to mention — which is why the method behind the 47-record census prints an unfilled field as "not yet recorded" rather than as concealment. The wrong reading of 13 of 91, and the one this article exists to prevent, is that 78 stores offer no warranty. Where a record and a page disagree, the page governs: VIOFO's record carries an "18-month warranty" line in its self-description while its refund policy is recorded at 12 months and its warranty policy at 18, or 24 after registration.

The one record that separates the two regimes. ELEGOO's record, last checked on 16 November 2026, draws the line in two sentences:

Quality issue in 14 days: ELEGOO pays return freight; refund, replacement or repair. Warranty quality issue: repair only, buyer pays freight.

Inside the return window all three remedies are available and the store pays the freight. Inside the warranty — the longer period the record invokes — the remedy narrows to repair alone, refund and replacement are refused in terms, and the freight passes to the buyer. A buyer who reads only the first clause has read the half that expires in two weeks. It is a limited warranty in the FTC's sense if ELEGOO offers that warranty with products sold in the United States — repair without the choice of replacement or refund fails test 4, and the Act does not require a full warranty. If it were labelled full there, the same terms would be a false label.

When the freight costs more than the goods

The question assumes the parcel goes back to China. Our records mostly do not say that. Three of the 91 name China or Hong Kong in the return summary, in three different roles: Naturehike's China dispatch as the reason international orders are not returnable unless there is a quality issue, Grace Karin's warehouse that "may be in Mexico, Italy or China", and Wurkkos's China hub, whose EU orders carry a clearance fee at checkout. TP-Link names no return address outside "the Chino, CA warranty depot" — a US address, for warranty service.

So establish where the thing goes before arguing about the bill. On who pays, the sources give you a way to read the answer rather than a rule. If the warranty is full, the freight is theirs — test 3 is service free of charge, and the sample limited warranty treats customer-paid postage as disqualifying. If it is limited, the label tells you only that something is missing, not what: postage, labour, a registration card, or a shortened implied-warranty period, which the guide permits expressly — "if you offer a 'limited' written warranty, the law allows you to include a provision that restricts the duration of implied warranties to the duration of your limited warranty." The clause answers the question, not the label.

Eight records put a freight term next to a warranty, written several ways. ELEGOO names the side that pays. TerraMaster's record has no return window at all: returns appear only as warranty claims, and the claim requires "freight paid by the customer both ways" and an RMA number on the carton. Xiaomi's record, read 10 November 2026, says return postage is "assigned to the buyer by Terms of Use clause 8.4 while two warranty-page sentences disagree." VIOFO's, read 4 November 2026, carries the only number in the set: the buyer pays return freight both ways unless the fault is VIOFO's, quality returns reimburse only up to US$20, and shipping may be charged after 90 days.

That US$20 is one store's cap on one date, not a market rate. It is enough to make the arithmetic concrete: against an international parcel holding a 3D printer or a power station it decides nothing, and a repair right whose freight exceeds the item's value is a right you cannot afford to use. Neither source addresses that case — the FTC page does not discuss freight costs or cross-border bills, and the ACCC page does not mention freight in its remedy list. What the FTC page supplies is a standard, not a procedure — a working product, or a remedy that gets you one — and a warning that you cannot offer a warranty that "appears to provide coverage but, in fact, provides none." So ask three things in writing before buying: where the unit goes, who pays freight both ways, and what the cap is.

If the product failed inside the return window, treat it as a return and use the checks in the ordering guide: the window is the promise the store made about returns, and the warranty is a separate promise whose terms on postage can differ.

What this guide does not cover

The Magnuson-Moss Act and the FTC's three Rules. Only the businessperson's guide was read, not the statute or the Rules it summarises.

The ACCC's linked guides, and any ranking of remedies. The page read lists remedies "depending on the situation" and does not say how to choose; the guide covering when each is available was not read, so no major-failure or minor-failure test is stated.

UK and EU consumer law. The legislation.gov.uk pages tried — the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 — returned empty responses when fetched on 15 November 2026, so no UK provision is quoted.

Who pays international freight as a matter of law. Neither source states a rule and this article does not invent one.

Card network and payment-processor dispute rules. Not read; no windows, grounds or figures appear here.

Any individual store's current warranty terms. Store facts come from our own record fields, read on the dates given; a record compresses a merchant's page, and where the two disagree the page governs.


Read for this article: the FTC's Businessperson's Guide to Federal Warranty Law at https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/businesspersons-guide-federal-warranty-law (HTTP 200, captured 15 November 2026) and the ACCC's Consumer rights and guarantees page at https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/buying-products-and-services/consumer-rights-and-guarantees (HTTP 200, captured 15 November 2026), both from snapshots taken that day; no live re-check was made on 18 November 2026. Every count — 91 published and approved store records, 13 mentioning a warranty, 1 repair, 2 replacement, 3 with a month or year in figures, 23 a defect, 23 a restocking fee, at least 59 buyer-pays, 34 seller-covers and 5 label-with-deduction, 3 naming China, Hong Kong or the Chinese market, 8 putting a freight term next to a warranty — is arithmetic over our own database, queried read-only on 18 November 2026 at 17:48 (UTC+08:00), and describes our record fields rather than the merchants' full pages. Record texts quoted were read from store pages on the dates given beside each. This summarises two regulators' published guidance and our own records; it is not legal advice, and it does not state that any named store has broken a rule.