The short answer
Three clocks run during a withdrawal, and none of them starts when you pay.
You have 14 days from the day the goods reach you to tell the seller; 14 days from that message to get the parcel back; and the seller has 14 days from your message to refund you, though it may wait until the goods arrive or you show that you sent them.
Two costs can be put on you, and the Directive names both: the direct cost of returning the goods, and a reduction for diminished value. A percentage of the order is neither, and none of the articles read for this guide introduces one.
Store pages are written for several markets at once, and the ones read here price a change of mind in percentages and flat sums — 5% or 15% at ELEGOO[5], 20% at Judydoll[7], 20% to 40% at LINSY[6], a $45 repackaging fee at Costway[4] — and 13 of the 91 store records in our database state a percentage charge on a return.
The gap is narrower than it looks: 50 of the 91 records give 30 days, longer than 14 and lawful. Inside the first 14 days, though, only the Directive is a floor.
Nothing below says a named store has broken a rule.
Day one is the day the parcel reaches you
Article 9(1) sets the period and its two limits in one sentence:
Save where the exceptions provided for in Article 16 apply, the consumer shall have a period of 14 days to withdraw from a distance or off-premises contract, without giving any reason, and without incurring any costs other than those provided for in Article 13(2) and Article 14.[1]
"Without giving any reason" disposes of most of the argument: no cause to show, no box to tick.
Article 9(2)(b) fixes the start, and it is not the order date, the payment date or the dispatch date:
in the case of sales contracts, the day on which the consumer or a third party other than the carrier and indicated by the consumer acquires physical possession of the goods or:[1]
The "or:" opens three cases: multiple goods ordered together but delivered separately run from the last good; a good delivered in multiple lots or pieces runs from the last lot or piece; and regular deliveries over a defined period run from the first good. A sofa in three boxes is the second case: one clock, on the last box.
Telling the seller is enough to stop it. Article 11(2) treats the right as exercised "if the communication concerning the exercise of the right of withdrawal is sent by the consumer before that period has expired".[1] The message need not be read or acknowledged, and the second 14 days run from it. The Commission's page adds a rule no store page we read repeats: "If the cooling-off period expires on a non-working day, your deadline is extended until the next working day."[3]
Article 10 is the article store policies almost never mention:
If the trader has not provided the consumer with the information on the right of withdrawal as required by point (h) of Article 6(1), the withdrawal period shall expire 12 months from the end of the initial withdrawal period, as determined in accordance with Article 9(2).[1]
Twelve months, not seven days: a short window on a page is not a short window in law.
Seven of the 91 summaries start the window at purchase rather than delivery: Amazfit, Anker, BLUETTI, ESR, Giantex, Govee and Ulike. ESR says it plainly — "30 days from the purchase date, not delivery". A 30-day clock from payment can expire before the statutory 14 days from delivery has begun, on a slow parcel.
What a page can add, and what it cannot subtract
The same clause is a ceiling on cost, not on generosity: "without incurring any costs other than those provided for in Article 13(2) and Article 14".[1]
A longer window is a promise with nothing to object to: 50 of the 91 summaries give 30 days, one 60, one 90, one 100, with the store's own conditions on the added part.
A shorter window is a different document. Four summaries state 7 days: FLORASIS, Keychron, Naturehike and Perfect Diary. Keychron is the useful case because it carries both on one page — a 7-day paragraph for everyone, then a section headed "Right of Withdrawal & Return Costs for EU Customers"[8] that restates the Directive and closes with the line that resolves the conflict:
For EU consumers, this section applies notwithstanding anything above.
That is the priority rule written out; most pages do not write it.
Baseus is subtler: our record shows a heading selling 7 days while the body counts business days — nine to eleven calendar days, longer than the figure reads. Article 9(1) states 14 calendar days; the comparison is between two texts, and working-day arithmetic changes the size of the gap, not what either text says.
For the UK the guidance to traders is blunt:
It’s illegal to restrict or take away customers’ rights or to mislead them about their rights, for example by displaying a sign that says you do not accept returns or offer refunds.[2]
That is about the law, addressed to sellers — not a finding about any store here.
The fee the Directive has no line for
Four provisions decide whether a return can cost a percentage. Article 13(1) sets the refund:
The trader shall reimburse all payments received from the consumer, including, if applicable, the costs of delivery without undue delay and in any event not later than 14 days from the day on which he is informed of the consumer’s decision to withdraw from the contract in accordance with Article 11.[1]
Article 13(2) carves out one payment: the supplement where the consumer "expressly opted for a type of delivery other than the least expensive type of standard delivery offered by the trader".[1]
Article 14(1) allows one further cost, and Article 14(2) allows a reduction rather than a fee:
The consumer shall only bear the direct cost of returning the goods unless the trader has agreed to bear them or the trader failed to inform the consumer that the consumer has to bear them.[1]
The consumer shall only be liable for any diminished value of the goods resulting from the handling of the goods other than what is necessary to establish the nature, characteristics and functioning of the goods.[1]
The list is closed: the delivery premium, return postage, and a valuation of damage beyond inspection. A restocking fee is not on it, nor a repackaging, handling or cleaning fee. "Only" does the work.
The UK guidance reaches the same place:
You must refund the customer within 14 days of receiving the item back. They do not have to provide a reason. You cannot deduct any fees from their refund, unless the item has been used or damaged.[2]
"Used or damaged" is a question of fact about one item. A schedule taking 15% off every opened box applies one rate to a category, where Article 14(2) speaks of the diminished value of the goods; the two are different measures.
What the pages charge
ELEGOO publishes two tables on one page. The first is headed "Return & Refund Policy(Excluding the UK)"[5] and carries a Restocking Fee column: "5% based on the order amount" for unopened goods inside 14 days, "15% based on the order amount" for open-box and unused, a row for used goods struck out. The same table puts "Customer" against original and return shipping.
Then comes a second heading, "UK Return & Refund Policy", whose table has no Restocking Fee column at all — the columns are Product Status, Items, Responsibility for Original Shipping Charges, Deduction Fee and Refund.[5]
That is the whole observation: on the page we read, the UK table has no column for the fee the other table charges, and we found no sentence explaining the omission. The two tables differ by one column heading; nothing on the page says which table applies to which buyer.
LINSY prices the idea by degree — a "RETURN CHARGE" of "20% of the actual payment amount of the order(s)" for a cancellation in transit, 25% received but unopened, 30% opened with the packaging intact, 40% opened with it damaged.[6] Judydoll charges "a handling fee of 20% of the selling price for the returned product", adding that "any original shipping costs or return shipping costs are non-refundable, unless it is an error on our part".[7] Costway uses a flat sum: "If you no longer have the original packaging, a repackaging fee of $45 will be charged per item, unless otherwise required by applicable law."[4]
That last clause writes the priority rule into the page's own sentence: the page itself defers to applicable law. That is a clause to read, not a finding about this store.
A trap in counting these
Search our 91 summary fields for restocking, repackaging, handling or cleaning and 26 records come back. Twelve summaries deny a fee: Anycubic, Autel, Dreo, Godox, Homerunpet, Midea, Mobi Garden, MOZA Racing, Neakasa, Renpho, VEVOR and Wolfbox. Ten contain the exact phrase "no restocking fee"; the phrase misses Wolfbox's "no 10% restocking fee" and Midea's statement that no restocking fee is published. Homerunpet and Renpho also charge one in a second document.
So 26 is not a count of stores that charge: it mixes denials with other vocabulary. Over the same 91 records, and counting a percentage only where it is stated as a charge, thirteen state a restocking or return percentage: Amazfit 15%, Aputure 15%, ELEGOO 5% or 15%, Heybike 20% to 50%, Huion 8%, Judydoll 20%, Kingroon 20% or 30%, Linsoul 35%, LINSY 20% to 40%, Nebula 10%, Renpho 15%, Segway 25%, Homary 10%. Four name a flat sum — CATLINK $50, Costway $45, Homerunpet $90 to $150, Ninebot $90 or $65 — two a fee with no rate (Jackery, Naturehike), and three a different deduction: EcoFlow 2.6% on card or 3.6% on PayPal, Mammotion 3.8% on card, 3.49% on PayPal or 3.8% on Klarna, xTool 6% to 45% for intercepting a parcel. The columns overlap — Renpho and Homerunpet also appear among the denials, because their documents contradict. The per-store list, and the exact-phrase count of ten, are in the delivery note.
Who pays to send it back
Article 14(1) makes return postage yours by default, then takes it back where the trader agreed to bear it or failed to tell you that you would.
The information duty behind the second is Article 6(1)(i): the trader must state "where applicable, that the consumer will have to bear the cost of returning the goods in case of withdrawal".[1] The Commission page puts it plainly:
If you decide to return the product within the 14-day cooling period, you are responsible for the costs of postage and packaging. The only exceptions: if the seller offers to pay, or if the seller fails to inform you about those costs before you buy.[3]
A page charging return postage without having said so relies on an exception that runs the other way. This is the one place in the right where silence helps the buyer.
Fifty-two of the 91 summaries match the freight phrases listed in the delivery note. Some name the price — Heybike $200 to $400 a bike, EcoFlow $11 to $88 by product; some the mechanism — Baleaf a US-only label at US$5 an item; most simply assign it, and Article 14(1) allocates that cost without capping it. The 52 is a phrase count: Narwal and Speediance put the cost on the buyer without using one of the phrases.
Keychron says both halves in one line:
Please return the goods to us within 14 days of telling us you wish to withdraw. You will bear the direct cost of returning the goods; where goods are defective or incorrectly supplied, we cover the return cost.[8]
That does what Article 14(1) requires: it tells you before you buy, so the cost is yours. Costway does the same with the same escape clause — "the return shipping costs will be the customer's responsibility, unless otherwise required by applicable law".[4]
The refund clock, and the delivery charge
Article 13(1) gives the trader 14 days "from the day on which he is informed of the consumer's decision to withdraw".[1] The trigger is your message, not the parcel's return, and the trader cannot extend it by being slow to open the box.
Two provisions soften that. Article 13(3) lets the trader withhold the money "until he has received the goods back, or until the consumer has supplied evidence of having sent back the goods, whichever is the earliest".[1] Article 13(1) requires the refund by the same means of payment, "unless the consumer has expressly agreed otherwise and provided that the consumer does not incur any fees as a result of such reimbursement".[1] Store credit is not the default; it needs your agreement and must cost you nothing.
The delivery charge comes back at the standard rate. Article 13(1) includes "the costs of delivery"; Article 13(2) removes only the supplement for a delivery type dearer than the cheapest standard option offered.
The UK guidance measures from a different event:
You must also refund the cost of standard delivery if the customer paid for it. If they paid for a more expensive delivery option, you only need to refund the cost of standard delivery.[2]
The delivery half matches; the clock does not. The same page says the refund is due "within 14 days of receiving the item back",[2] where Article 13(1) counts from the consumer's message. Both are 14 days from different events, and a guide printing one start date for both markets is wrong about one. Which the UK statute says is outside this guide.
Our records contain the sentence Article 13(1) was written against. PETKIT's page says:
Original shipping charges are non-refundable unless otherwise required by law or due to a verified product quality issue.[10]
Read alone, that keeps outbound postage on a change of mind. Article 13(1) includes the costs of delivery among the payments to be reimbursed; the comparison is between the clause and the article, not a finding about this store. Costway gives the arithmetic version: "we will issue a refund within 7 business days, minus return shipping fees (except for returns due to quality issues)".[4] Seven business days sits inside the 14-day ceiling. The deduction is the part to read against Article 13(1).
The goods the 14 days never covered
Article 16 does not create exceptions a store may apply; it removes the right at member-state level:
Member States shall not provide for the right of withdrawal set out in Articles 9 to 15 in respect of distance and off-premises contracts as regards the following:[1]
Two categories matter most:
the supply of goods made to the consumer’s specifications or clearly personalised;[1]
the supply of sealed goods which are not suitable for return due to health protection or hygiene reasons and were unsealed after delivery;[1]
The hygiene limb has three elements, all of which must hold: sealed, unsuitable for return for health or hygiene reasons, unsealed after delivery. Underwear and opened cosmetics fit; a camera in an opened box does not.
Article 16 removes the statutory right, not the store's freedom to accept the return anyway — a distinction most pages blur.
"Unopened items only" is the blur. Sixteen of our summaries use opened, unopened, sealed or hygiene language, almost all as a condition on the store's own return: we will take it back if the seal is intact. That is a narrower offer than the Directive, not a statement that the right does not exist.
The category that stores add and Article 16 lacks is the sale. Twelve summaries exclude final-sale, clearance, sale or discounted items: Balabala, Baleaf, CATLINK, Cider, Giantex, Grace Karin, Kingroon, Momcozy, MOZA Racing, Sharge, Wurkkos and Yeedi. Article 16 is about what the goods are, not what they cost; the UK guidance makes the point from the other side: "Customers have exactly the same rights to refunds when they buy items in a sale as when they buy them at full price."[2]
Personalised goods are the category stores get right, narrowly: four summaries mention a personalised, customised or engraved exclusion — Bamoer for engraved items, Fanttik, Linsoul and MOZA Racing.
The Commission's list is a different length: it names eight categories and omits the sealed hygiene limb of Article 16(e).[3] The UK guidance has it: "sealed items that for health or hygiene reasons cannot be returned once they have been opened, for example underwear".[2] A reader checking only the Commission page would conclude opened cosmetics are returnable, and would be wrong.
What the 91 records say
Every number below comes from data/oversea.db, read-only, over the 91 records with status='published' AND review_state='approved'. The fields compress pages: a blank field is not a finding, and where field and page disagree, the page governs.
The window. We read each return_policy_summary for the change-of-mind figure it states; a record that gives two or more change-of-mind figures — product-tier and holiday variations included — is counted once under "more than one". Defect, warranty or after-sales windows, mailing deadlines, refund timings, exchange-only limits and restatements of the statutory right are not a second figure.
| Figure stated | Records |
|---|---|
| 7 days | 4 |
| 14 days | 9 |
| 15 days | 4 |
| 30 days | 50 |
| 60 days | 1 |
| 90 days | 1 |
| 100 days | 1 |
| more than one figure | 20 |
| no window at all | 1 |
The 50 at 30 days are the centre of gravity, and where the fee schedules live. The 20 with more than one figure state a second window in various ways — often through a product tier, a holiday variation or a second document, sometimes through two figures on one page; the summary does not say which figure governs the day you are on. The policy census measured the narrower case of two documents disagreeing, 14 of 47 records. The one with no window is TERRAMASTER (warranty claims, no change-of-mind return).
The money. Over the 91 records: 13 state a restocking or return percentage, 4 a flat sum, 2 a fee with no rate, 3 a transaction or interception percentage, and 12 deny a fee (Renpho and Homerunpet also appear in a charging column).
The postage. 52 match the freight regex — each field assigns the return freight to the buyer or customer in one of the listed phrases. The regex and the 52 matched phrases are in the delivery note, so each match can be checked.
What the field cannot tell you. No summary field contains "unless otherwise required by applicable law", though three published store reviews quote a store sentence that does — BLUETTI, Costway, PETKIT. A compression drops a conditional clause first, which argues for reading the page rather than the field.
What this guide does not cover
Whether a particular store is inside the Directive. Article 2 fixes the scope, but whether a trader is directing activity at consumers in a member state is a legal question about that trader, and a shipping list does not answer it. Services, digital content and off-premises sales fall under different Article 16 rules, and no carrier's price list was read either.
The UK statute. The Consumer Contracts (Information, Cancellation and Additional Charges) Regulations 2013 and the Consumer Rights Act 2015 were not read: both legislation.gov.uk URLs tried on 16 November 2026 returned HTTP 202 with a body that decoded to no text. The UK side rests on GOV.UK's guidance[2] alone, and where the two differ — the refund trigger in particular — this guide reports both and picks neither.
National implementing measures, enforcement and remedies. Each member state transposes the Directive, and the transposition is what a consumer enforces; none was read here. Who to complain to, and what a regulator would make of a fee schedule, are also outside this guide.
Notes
- Directive 2011/83/EU, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32011L0083 — HTTP 200, 301,120 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:04 UTC. Articles quoted above; no consolidated or amending text was read.
- GOV.UK, Accepting returns and giving refunds: the law, https://www.gov.uk/accepting-returns-and-giving-refunds — HTTP 200, 74,763 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:04 UTC. Guidance to traders, not an Act or Statutory Instrument.
- European Commission, Returns and the right of withdrawal, Your Europe, https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/shopping/returns/index_en.htm — HTTP 200, 155,063 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:04 UTC. Its exceptions list names eight categories.
- Costway, Cancel & Return Policy, https://www.costway.com/cancel-return-policy — HTTP 200, 416,087 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:04 UTC.
- ELEGOO, Return & Refund Policy, https://www.elegoo.com/pages/refund-policy — HTTP 200, 948,601 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:05 UTC. Both tables read column by column.
- LINSY, Policy, https://linsy.com/pages/policy — HTTP 200, 104,388 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:05 UTC.
- Judydoll, Refund Policy, https://judydoll.com/policies/refund-policy — HTTP 200, 512,943 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:05 UTC.
- Keychron, Refund Policy, https://www.keychron.com/policies/refund-policy — HTTP 200, 1,916,832 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:05 UTC.
- BLUETTI, After-Sales Policy, https://www.bluetti.com/support/after-sales-policy — HTTP 200, 78,374 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:10 UTC. Cited only for "Orders are non-cancelable and non-returnable once accepted by BLUETTI, except as required by applicable law…".
- PETKIT, Return & Refund Policy, https://www.petkit.com/pages/return-refund-policy — HTTP 200, 588,254 bytes, 16 Nov 2026 23:10 UTC.
Record counts
select slug, return_policy_summary
from stores
where status='published' and review_state='approved'
order by slug; -- 91 rows
Windows. Assigned by hand: the field mixes return windows with mailing deadlines and refund timings, and a record giving two or more change-of-mind figures — product-tier and holiday variations included — counts once. Warranty, after-sales, mailing, refund, exchange and statutory-restatement figures are not a second figure. Cider, SmallRig and Sweetnight are the product-tier or holiday cases now under "more than one"; the delivery note's first-draft assignment predates that correction.
Buyer pays return freight: 52. Regex applied to return_policy_summary:
/buyer pays|customer pays|consumer pays|customer is responsible|customer's responsibility|at the customer's expense|you pay|you are responsible|buyer prepays|the customer pays|the buyer pays|customer bears|buyer bears/i
Vocabulary check. /restocking|restock fee|repackaging|handling fee|cleaning fee/i returns 26 records, 12 of them semantic denials (10 contain the exact phrase "no restocking fee") — not a count of practice.
The ten pages were fetched on 16 November 2026 between 23:04 and 23:11 UTC, each returning HTTP 200 with the byte count given; two legislation.gov.uk URLs, tried at 23:09 UTC, returned HTTP 202 with no readable body. Nothing here is legal advice, and none of it states that a named store has broken a rule.